Share:

Facebook
LinkedIn
WhatsApp

Esther Cailingold:
A religious soldier who fought and was killed in the final battle for the Old City in 1948

Words written by Prof. Margalit Shilo, of the Department of Land of Israel Studies and Archaeology at Bar-Ilan University, about 25 years ago in the “Kolech” leaflet, which appear in the book edited by Rachel Keren: Hashmi’ini Et Kolech (Let Me Hear Your Voice): Studies on the Yearly Cycle and Weekly Torah Portions, The Decennial Book of Kolech, Rubin Mass Publishing, Jerusalem, 2009, pp. 253–256.

These words quote from a book of Cailingold’s letters: “She was one of the few young women who took an active part in the fighting, actual combat, in the War of Independence. Even within the garrison sent to the Old City, most of the women served in roles as nurses, cooks, or quartermasters. Out of the 1,200 soldiers in the Harel Brigade, for example, four hundred were women, but only five actually fought” (p. 211).

These sentences are included in a moving book written and published by Asher Cailingold more than fifty years after the fall of his sister, Esther Cailingold. The book, From London to Jerusalem: The Story of a Fighter in the Haganah (2003, translated by Ada Paldor), was written following the late discovery of a suitcase containing her letters. Selected passages from the book are interwoven in my words.

From the book, an extraordinary figure emerges of a young Jewish woman, Esther, who had not yet turned 23 at the time of her fall in the War of Independence. She was a combat soldier,
but her military activity was only one aspect of her impressive and multifaceted personality.
By casting a glance at her unknown figure, we are not only fulfilling a boundless debt to cherish the memory of the fallen who are “the silver platter upon which the Jewish state was given”
but also enriching our world by getting to know a multi-talented young woman rich in deeds.

The short life of Cailingold, a religious young woman and a feminist, is a torch of fire worthy
of lighting our way. Cailingold, born in London, was the daughter of an observant Jewish family that immigrated to England from the Krakow area. She graduated with honors from a high school that engraved on its banner a revolutionary message: that its female students are capable of reaching the highest levels of academic success, and can aspire to senior positions in any profession they choose (p. 28).

Esther immigrated to Jerusalem from Britain on her own initiative, driven by Religious-Zionist motives. Upon her arrival in the autumn of 1946, she served as a teacher at the Evelina de Rothschild School. Shortly after arriving in the country, Esther wrote:
“I probably made a subconscious decision in advance to love everything from the very first moment, so that even if
I am excited and impressed by everything I see and do,
it is all biased, I say this honestly, because perhaps I am looking at everything around me through rose-colored glasses. But I am so happy, so happy, that I realize that in the past there were only very rare chapters in my life where I knew what happiness meant…” (p. 67).

The impact of immigrating to Israel (Aliyah) is described by her, as by quite a few immigrants,
as a rebirth (p. 71). Her great admiration is not only for the transformation she herself is undergoing, but mainly for the transformation the land is undergoing:
“This is a completely new land, although it is so old, and if one stops for a moment to think or look at what has already been done here in only fifty or seventy years, it is so amazing…”

About a year after her arrival, around November 29, 1947 the date of the UN resolution on the partition of the Land of Israel Esther enlisted in the Haganah, joining a group of religious young women. They belonged to the most active branch of the Haganah but did not train on the Sabbath. At this time, she still continued her teaching work at the Evelina school, and in her letters to her family, she revealed a little of her daring deeds while concealing much more.

A friend wrote about her history: “At first, she was posted at Kibbutz Tzuba, where she engaged in cooking for the drafted men and where she apparently learned to use a weapon.
Within a short time, she began to get bored with cooking… and asked to undergo real training…
After a stubborn struggle over her role… she passed a series of training sessions… Later they posted her in Neve Yaakov… and the men who were there recount that when Neve Yaakov was attacked, she took a rifle and went out to battle too… she fired and hit several of the attackers.”

The story of the soldier Esther is typical of the stories of young women in the Haganah.
On one hand, they hurried to recruit and train them; on the other hand, they sought to exclude them from combat activity. Only the most stubborn young women “won” advanced training. From the wording of her friend’s letter, it appears that Esther’s participation in battle also occurred due to her personal initiative.

Her courage was amazing. The encounter with the death of her friends and her enemies did not deter her. In a letter to her parents in London, she wrote:
“I am indeed not sorry for a moment that I am here in these great and stormy times,
and I wouldn’t dream of leaving, but still, you are lucky you aren’t here, and the heartbreak is spared from you. Now I know what it means to suffer for this land…” (p. 161).

The casualties that fell on every side not only failed to deter her, but on the contrary, spurred her to abandon civilian life and dedicate herself to the military struggle. She wrote to her parents:
“Now I am a full-time soldier, and quite busy, but I beg of you not to worry.”

Her commander added: “She was the first girl among us to wear a uniform” (p. 170). “[Esther] claimed that girls can perform guard duties at posts no less well than the boys, and sometimes even better than them, and thus be full partners in responsibility, and free the men for actual fighting” (p. 179).

Esther’s feminist stance is complex. She possesses initiative and self-confidence, charting a path for her female friends to participate in combat. Her perception is that equality does not mean sameness, nor does it mean adopting male capabilities, but rather a full partnership in taking responsibility. Alongside participating in actual combat, she also finds other worthy pursuits: she broadcasts in English (her mother tongue) on the Haganah’s underground radio station, she engages in intelligence activities, she visits the wounded, and she writes articles for the Jewish Agency’s publication, Letter to the Diaspora.

Esther’s “otherness” being a new immigrant and being religiously observant not only did not distance her from the other soldiers, but were additional characteristics that impressed her many friends. Her commander recounted: “The whole time we served together, Esther remained very religious and kept all the rules of religion… I was surprised to discover how many people knew and loved her… everyone wanted to exchange a few words with her” (p. 206).

The desire for full partnership in responsibility leads Esther to the most daring and dangerous step joining the final battle of the Jewish Quarter fighters in May 1948. In the Old City, she serves as a signal operator (runner): “She went from post to post, encouraged our people, and asked what they needed. She had a kind of special tranquility, and she would slip past shells and bullets without any sign of fear” (p. 221).

…until she was critically injured by a massive explosion and passed away a few days later. What drove Esther, the new immigrant, to go specifically there? In her final letter to her parents, a week after arriving in the Quarter and six days before her death, she expressed her deep connection to Jerusalem: “We fought for the greatest and noblest cause of all. God is with us, I know, in His holy city, His very own city” (p. 252).

Esther was fully aware of her actions. In that same letter, she wrote: “I have no regrets myself. We had a bitter fight, I have tasted hell – but it has been worthwhile because I am convinced that in the end there will be a Jewish State and the realization of all our longings… I shall only be one of many who fell sacrifice (ibid)… Remember me with joy” (p. 259).

With these words, she concluded her final letter to her parents. Her words, moving to this day, leave no dry eye, yet they also assure us that our winding path has been paved and continues to be paved thanks to spiritual strengths like those of Esther Cailingold, the soldier from London, which shine like a burning torch even after they have been extinguished.

About Us | Women's Prayer Project

The “Women’s Prayer” project began two decades ago as a book that documented and collected Jewish women’s prayers throughout history. The book, which became a bestseller, revealed an entire world that had almost disappeared from our sight – a breathing and vibrant Jewish-feminine space that reflects a Jewish life story that was almost never told through conventional historical tools.

Today, marking 20 years since the book’s publication, we are proud to expand the project to a new format of prayer cards, combining the ancient prayers together with images from a stunning Judaica collection (courtesy of the William Gross Collection, photography: Arnon Barmucha).

The cards are intended for daily use, personal contemplation, family ceremonies and community activities – they invite us to return and reconnect with the rich feminine tradition that passed from mother to daughter throughout the generations.

Our Books

Women’s Prayer Cards (Tefilat Nashim) We use cookies to ensure the website functions properly and improve user experience. You can choose which types of cookies to enable.
Cookie Selection


Join us for women's prayer

A connection to the Jewish story through women’s voices
Join to receive sources, prayers, rituals and stories from the Jewish female tradition.